395
a wear pattern that looks like brinnelling but involves no impact. Doesn’t really matter which, either way the bearings
are ruined.
Gran Turismo Jaguar (now defunct) offered a kit to replace the tapered roller bearing idea entirely with brass bushings.
Concours West (page 706) offers urethane bushings. Either of these has the considerable benefit of being an order of
magnitude easier to install, since there is no need for adjustment and fiddling with shims.
However, whether or not going to bushings is actually an improvement is far from clear. First, note that the entire point
of renewing these bearings is to eliminate sources of slop in this joint, but you cannot adjust the slop out of bushings. If
the bushings don’t fit very snugly on the fulcrum shaft, the slop may get worse rather than better. And even if the
bushings are really snug, of course, any wear in those bushings would cause slop -- if you’re unlucky, more slop than
would be caused by the wear rate of the OEM tapered roller bearings.
There’s also the question of the quality of design and construction. For example, the OEM assembly provides a stack
of parts all the way through the assembly so that the fulcrum nuts can be torqued down tight without being concerned
about distorting the fork on the end of the swingarm. The same stack clearly won’t work since there are no longer any
inner bearing races, so a well-designed bushing set would either provide a single sleeve to surround the fulcrum shaft
and fit inside the bushings, or short sleeves for use with the OEM spacer tubes. Steve Stewart says, “The solid bushes I
put in the E-type were from Classic Jaguar in Texas (
www.classicjaguar.com
). No sleeves at all. The shafts fit straight
through the bushings which are a nice push-in fit to the hub carrier and wishbones.” Apparently you must be careful
not to overtorque the fulcrum nuts so as not to distort the swingarm.
Seals are apparently another issue. Stewart continues: “I don't believe that grease retention is as good as the roller
bearing set up though as there are no seals used. Also instruction to grease these every 3000 miles or so.”
Actually, urethane or nylon bushings might be better than brass or bronze. With plastic, it may be possible to assemble
a really tight fit, and wear could be minimal if the load distribution is within the capacity of the plastic. The plastic
bushing might serve as a seal without requiring a separate seal; it might even be molded with a sealing lip. It still
should have a metal sleeve around the fulcrum shaft, though.
All in all, it might be best to just maintain the OEM roller bearings properly and replace them periodically when they
get worn. They are not expensive, and replacement is pretty easy.
REAR SWINGARM OUTER PIVOT - SEALS: One common suggestion here is to reverse the felt seal and cup
during assembly, but this is probably because the exploded diagram in the Parts Catalogue shows the felt seal and cup
backwards and these people have just figured out the way it’s supposed to go.
Even installed correctly, there is considerable history of rust, corrosion, and water damage with the outer pivot
bearings. Craig Sawyers says, “The truly awful felt seal ships water like you would expect; it simply acts like a wick.”
In his column “Tech Talk” in Edition 82 of The Jaguar Magazine, Ron Moore recommends the seal C20178, its
container C20179, and its retaining washer C20182 be omitted; if you printed this book in color, these parts are shown
in magenta in Figure 22. In their place, Moore recommends a “common oil seal PR6354” be installed instead --
backwards, with the flat side of the seal facing the bearing.
More info on that seal: PR6354 is a Repco part number, and it cross-references to a Federal-Mogul/National 471652 or
a C-R 11124. Timken also calls this seal a 471652. The dimensions of this seal are 1.125 x 1.624 x 0.250. Duncan
Williamson says that Farrell Bearings Ltd stores in New Zealand provide a seal number TC12044 23560R. Sawyers
reports that Classic Spares (page 690) offers an “outer fulcrum bearing kit” that includes the bearings, an assortment of
shims, and suitable oil seals instead of the OEM felt seals.
Moore has a point about that backwards installation. Seals are normally used to keep fluids in, but in this case they are
used to keep fluids out. The main lip within such a seal, which has a spring behind it, will hold fluids securely in the
direction that would result in fluids coming out the flat side, but not as securely in the direction of fluid entering the flat
side.